← | 063 - Which Finger? | 064 - Who Broke It? | 065 - Strange Shapes | → |
Who Broke It? (Break Time in the UK version) is a puzzle in Professor Layton and the Unwound Future.
Puzzle
- US Version
One of these people broke the window. When asked about it, they gave the following statements in order, starting with A.
A: "I didn't do it."
B: "A is telling the truth."
C: "D is lying."
D: "I swear it wasn't me."
The person whose story sounds fishy is the culprit. Who is it?
- UK Version
One of these students broke a window, so you ask each of them who did it, in order.
A: "I didn't do it."
B: "A is telling the truth."
C: "D is lying."
D: "It certainly wasn't me."
The one whose story sounds fishy is the culprit. Who is it?
Hints
Solution
Incorrect
- US Version
Too bad!
Remember, their statements were given in order.
- UK Version
Too bad.
Ask them again, "in order".
Correct
- US Version
Brilliant deduction!
C is indeed the culprit. He said that D was lying before D had ever spoken!
Clearly something's up with C.
- UK Version
That's right!
C broke the window.
He said that D was lying, even though D hadn't spoken yet.
It doesn't get any fishier than that!
Professor Layton and the Unwound Future | Puzzles in||
---|---|---|
Normal |
| |
Weekly | See here for weekly puzzles. | |
Hidden Door | ||
Puzzle Index: CV · DB · UF · LS · MM · AL · VS |